Best Plastic Pellet Gun for Squirrels: Safe Backyard Pest Control

For effective, humane pest control in residential settings, selecting a suitable plastic pellet gun can make a difference in accuracy, safety, and ease of use. This article reviews five consumer-grade options that are popular for backyard pest management and target practice alike. Each pick balances power, ease of operation, and reliability, with considerations for legal compliance and safety. The following sections highlight key features, performance notes, and practical use cases to help you choose the right model for controlling small pests like squirrels.

Buying Guide Snapshot

Product Caliber Approx. Power Special Features
Barra Sportsman 900 .177 Up to 800 FPS Multi-pump option, scope, bolt-action
Umarex Strikepoint .177 Variable by pumps 5-chamber SilencAir suppressor
H&N Hunting Sampler .177 N/A Assorted pellets for testing
Umarex Browning Buck Mark URX .177 Up to 360 fps Single-shot, break-barrel
Barra 1866 Cowboy Series .177 Up to 800 fps Lever-action feel, multi-pump

Barra Sportsman 900 Pellet Rifle

Barra Sportsman 900 Pellet Rifle

Check Price on Amazon

The Barra Sportsman 900 combines versatility with a modern look and multiple power options. It supports either .177 caliber pellets or BBs, enabling a choice between precision targets and casual plinking. A 20-inch rifled barrel helps stabilize pellets for consistent accuracy, while included fiber optic sights and a 4×15 scope enhance aiming capability. The multi-pump action and real working bolt-action design provide a familiar feel for both new and experienced shooters. Load up to 50 BBs or one pellet at a time for flexible shooting sessions.

Umarex Strikepoint .177 Pellet Airgun

Umarex Strikepoint .177 Pellet Airgun

Check Price on Amazon

The Umarex Strikepoint is a single-shot, multi-pump pneumatic pellet air pistol designed for stealth and control. Its 5-chamber SilencAir sound dampener reduces noise, making it suitable for use where noise reduction matters. With a user-controlled number of pumps (3 to 10), you can adjust energy output to suit your target or environment. This model emphasizes quiet operation and consistent power, offering a good balance between accuracy and discretion for small pest management tasks.

H&N Hunting Sampler .177 Pellets

H&N Hunting Sampler Pellets

Check Price on Amazon

This H&N Hunting Sampler provides a broad test bed of .177 pellets across different grains, letting you identify the best match for your chosen rifle. The 215-count assortment supports trials for stability, expansion, and accuracy under varied conditions. For pest control where precision matters, selecting the right weight pellet can improve hit probability on small targets like squirrels while minimizing pellet drop-off over distance.

Umarex Browning Buck Mark URX

Umarex Browning Buck Mark URX Pellet Gun

Check Price on Amazon

The Browning Buck Mark URX is a compact, single-shot break-barrel air pistol chambered in .177. It fires pellets at up to 360 fps, offering a lightweight alternative for casual backyard shooting. The stainless-steel feel and ergonomic, ambidextrous grip make extended sessions comfortable. While not the most powerful option, its simplicity and ease of use can be advantageous for precise, short-range pest control on smaller targets.

Barra 1866 Cowboy Series Lever Action

Barra 1866 Cowboy Series Lever Action

Check Price on Amazon

The Barra 1866 Cowboy Series emulates a lever-action rifle and shoots both pellets and BBs, delivering a classic look with modern multi-pump mechanics. With a maximum velocity around 800 fps, it is a robust option for backyard pest work and general plinking. The built-in reservoir and adjustable power levels from 1 to 10 pumps enable tailored shot energy, supporting careful pest management without excessive power that could risk unintended damage.

Buying Guide: Key Purchase Considerations

  • Caliber and ammunition type: .177 is common for pest control and target shooting; ensure you can choose between pellets and BBs where offered and confirm compatibility with your rifle or pistol.
  • Power and velocity: Select a model with adjustable pump or power settings to balance effectiveness and safety. Higher FPS may improve hit probability but could increase noise and recoil.
  • Accuracy features: Look for rifled barrels, scopes, and fiber optic sights. A stable optic setup helps in consistently hitting small targets at moderate ranges.
  • Operating mechanism: Multi-pump, lever-action, and break-barrel designs each have distinct handling traits. Choose one that matches your comfort level and intended use.
  • Noise considerations: Quiet operation is preferable for backyards with neighbors. Some models integrate integrated silencers or dampening features.
  • Safety and legality: Check local regulations regarding airguns, required safety features (eye protection recommendations, safe storage), and any permit requirements.
  • Durability and maintenance: Metal construction and simple field-stripping can extend life. Consider models with readily available replacement parts and pellets compatible with your rifle/barrel.
  • Target suitability: For small pests such as squirrels, prioritize models with adequate velocity and predictable point-of-impact performance at typical backyard distances.
  • Cost of ownership: Include pellets, BBs, scopes, and maintenance supplies in your budgeting to avoid surprises over time.
  • Use case balance: If target practice and pest control both matter, select a versatile platform that offers both accurate shooting and practical power for tiny game management.